The actors are on their game, with Long digging deeper than he's usually asked to, and Wood showing more restraint than she often does.
Elizabeth Weitzman, New York Daily News, 2013-11-07
"A Case of You" is perfectly enjoyable as far as indie rom coms go - just not particularly original.
Annlee Ellingson, Los Angeles Times, 2013-11-05
A Case Of You's characters and plot points will be familiar to anyone who's seen a movie in which a neurotic urbanite pines for a beautiful girl.
Ignatiy Vishnevetsky, AV Club, 2013-11-06
While this unrelentingly midtempo movie milks Brooklyn for its chic, it manages to denude it of its color.
Andy Webster, New York Times, 2013-11-05
A Case of You is a disappointing romantic comedy that aspires to social relevance until the third act, when it settles for pat Freudian revelations.
Inkoo Kang, Village Voice, 2013-11-05
Wood makes Birdie approachable enough that Sam's continuing treatment of her as a fantasy-girl, who could only like a fictionalized version of him, grows tiresome as the film progresses.
John DeFore, Hollywood Reporter, 2013-11-04