instantwatcher.com

This Film Is Not Yet Rated

01rate Kirby Dick's provocative documentary investigates the secretive and inconsistent process by which the Motion Picture Association of America rates films, revealing the organization's underhanded efforts to control culture. Dick questions whether certain studios get preferential treatment and exposes the discrepancies in how the MPAA views sex and violence. Interviewees include John Waters, Darren Aronofsky, Maria Bello, Atom Egoyan and more.
Netflix Rating: 3.5
NYT Critics' Pick
Kirby Dick, with the help of a private detective, investigates the mysterious workings of the MPAA, a highly secretive, deeply irrational organization with enormous influence over what we see -- and don't see -- on movie screens. Read the review
Top Rotten Tomatoes Critics

The ABC's of G, PG, PG-13, R, and NC-17 are a knotty business, one that the Oscar-nominated Kirby tries valiantly and amusingly to untangle. full review

Joanne Kaufman, Wall Street Journal

A movie that is at once eye-opening and hilarious. full review

Peter Howell, Toronto Star

a head-spinning mystery, a brisk history of motion picture censorship in the U.S. and entertaining, often hilarious, visual proof of Hollywood's hypocrisy in his latest film. full review

Jennie Punter, Globe and Mail

It makes a good case for some all-American free enterprise to come up with an alternative. full review

David Germain, Associated Press

...A ringing indictment of a system that's not just broken. It's rigged and needs replacing. full review

Roger Moore, Orlando Sentinel

You can tell that Dick, whose previous documentary Derrida showed that he had serious chops, is having fun with this one. And a good part of the fun involves providing entertaining educational highlights for the public.

Robert Denerstein, Denver Rocky Mountain News

Winds up feeling shallow, padded and unrevealing. full review

Michael Booth, Denver Post

Although a couple of the film's conclusions are as arbitrary and questionable as decisions by the board, This Film Is Not Yet Rated should be an eye-opener. full review

Terry Lawson, Detroit Free Press

This Film Is Not Yet Rated may be a mischievous, slanted and even angry piece of work, but it articulates a rage that filmmakers and film consumers have felt for years. full review

Chris Vognar, Dallas Morning News

[Dick's] recordings and reenactments of his skirmishes with the MPAA's executives and lawyers make the association look like a fatuous kangaroo court that rules by fiat rather than reason.

Colin Covert, Minneapolis Star Tribune

A flawed but also very funny and very welcome attack on the motion picture ratings board. full review

Richard Roeper, Ebert & Roeper

Extremely amusing and as close a look as you're likely to get at the mysterious workings of this self-appointed regulatory agency. full review

Ruthe Stein, San Francisco Chronicle

Thumbing one's nose at prudes can be fun, but it can also be childish and ultimately patronizing. full review

Jonathan Rosenbaum, Chicago Reader

Dick doesn't exactly blow the lid off the organization, but he lifts it enough to see what an outrageously flawed outfit we're dealing with. full review

Wesley Morris, Boston Globe

At its best, This Film Is Not Yet Rated, Kirby Dick's hugely entertaining catalog of MPAA follies, inventories the inconsistencies of the institution that has rated films for 40 years.

Carrie Rickey, Philadelphia Inquirer

It's fun for a while. Then you realize all this Michael Moore-ish folderol is weakening the movie's strongest arguments. full review

Michael Phillips, Chicago Tribune

The same story in print would move more fleetly and makes its points more adroitly. full review

Richard Nilsen, Arizona Republic

... a jazzy jeremiad that dances around the whole dilemma of ratings. full review

Richard Corliss, TIME Magazine

For a film with this much argument in it, This Film is remarkably entertaining. full review

Philip Kennicott, Washington Post
full review by Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Similars Available on Instant
  • Release Year: 2006
  • MPAA Rating: NR
  • Runtime: 90 min
  • Available From: Jul 15, 2010
  • Available Until: Dec 31, 2099
  • Remaining: 31631 days left
  • Queued by: 924 people
Directed By
Kirby Dick
Cast
Darren Aronofsky, Maria Bello, Mary Harron, Matt Stone, Kimberly Peirce, John Waters, Kevin Smith, Atom Egoyan
Genres

Related Items at Amazon.com